The field of digital health innovation is booming, but navigating patent eligibility can be complex. Discover key strategies for protecting your inventions and bringing them to market in this informative article.
In recent years, digital health has emerged as a rapidly growing field, with a range of technologies such as telemedicine, wearable devices, and digital therapeutics becoming increasingly popular. Know more on Digital Health Patent Eligibility in this blog!
While these technologies have the potential to revolutionise healthcare and improve patient outcomes, they also raise complex legal and regulatory questions, particularly when it comes to patent eligibility.
Navigating uncertainty in digital health patent eligibility is crucial for innovators seeking to protect their inventions and bring them to market.
Know about: Patent laws in India
Patent Eligibility in India
In India, the Patent Act, 1970, governs patent eligibility. According to the act, inventions that are new, non-obvious, and capable of industrial application are eligible for patent protection.
However, certain categories of inventions are not patentable, including inventions contrary to public order or morality, methods of agriculture or horticulture, and software per se. The last category has been the subject of much debate in recent years, particularly in the context of digital health.
What Can You Protect in Digital Health?
Consider different aspects of your digital health innovation. For example, electronic devices, software, apps, AI, and data-driven approaches, when deciding whether to pursue a patent.
Software and apps that help with health, well-being, and treatment can be protected with patents because they do more than just regular software. They can actually help patients in the real world.
If the software does things outside the computer, like diagnosing health problems, controlling medical devices, or processing medical images, it might be able to get a patent.
It’s also important to think about different ways to protect your software innovation.
For example, you can collect data from a person’s wearable device and use it in a creative way to give them health information. That data can also be used to teach a computer program to find signs of illness in other people. Both of these ideas could be protected by a patent.
If you use artificial intelligence (AI) in your invention, you can get a patent for both the training phase of the AI program and its actual use.
Just using AI by itself is not enough to make something qualify for a patent.
If you start with a simple invention, like organising data, using AI to help with it might not be enough to get a patent.
But if the AI program does something important, like finding diseases, creating medicine, or analysing medical images, it might be eligible for a patent.
For example, using a special computer program to study changes in heart function from a heart test can be patented because it helps doctors understand a patient’s heart health. The computer device that provides this information can also be patented.
Apps can also be patented if they have a real impact.
This impact can be directly related to what the app does, like monitoring a person’s sleep and giving advice to help them sleep better.
The design of the app’s buttons and screens can also be protected by a patent if they make it easier for people with disabilities to use the app or if they make it simple for anyone to use.
While methods of diagnosing and treating illnesses can’t be patented, the devices used to do those things can be patented. The software that runs on those devices and makes them work can also be protected by a patent.
There are no strict rules against getting patents for inventions related to medical engineering, providing healthcare advice, or creating devices for medical procedures.
|
Protecting your ideas and innovations with Intellectual Property (IP) can bring great value to your business. It gives you an advantage in the market and shows that you have carefully planned your business, making it more attractive to potential investors. IP comes in various forms, each designed to protect different types of innovations |
Key Considerations for Digital Health Filings
Detailed descriptions:
Provide specific and detailed descriptions of your digital health innovation in the patent application.
Technical effects:
Highlight the technical effects of your software or app, such as improved diagnosis or treatment outcomes.
Inventive step:
Demonstrate how your digital health innovation goes beyond existing solutions and offers something new and inventive.
Careful drafting:
Pay attention to the drafting of your patent application, ensuring clarity and accuracy in describing the technical aspects.
Patent eligibility:
Understand that digital health innovations are not automatically excluded from patentability, so explore the potential for securing patent protection.
Different aspects:
Consider the various aspects of your digital health innovation, such as hardware, software, AI, data analysis, and user interfaces, to determine which aspects may be patentable.
Competitive advantage:
Recognise that patents can provide a competitive edge in the market and enhance the value of your digital health business.
Professional guidance:
Seek guidance from intellectual property experts with experience in the digital health sector to navigate the complexities of the filing process
Navigating Uncertainty in Digital Health Patent Eligibility
Patent eligibility is one of the key challenges facing innovators in the digital health space. Given the rapid pace of technological change in this field, it can be difficult to predict how patent offices and courts will interpret and apply existing legal standards.
The following are some of the key areas of uncertainty that innovators should be aware of when seeking to protect their digital health inventions:
Software Patents
One of the biggest challenges facing innovators in the digital health space is the question of whether software can be patented. While the Patent Act does not explicitly exclude software from patent eligibility, the Indian Patent Office has recently hesitated to grant software patents.
In particular, the office has been reluctant to grant patents for software deemed ‘business methods’ or ‘mathematical algorithms’. This has led to uncertainty for innovators who are seeking to protect their digital health inventions, many of which rely on software algorithms to function.
Medical Methods
Another area of uncertainty in digital health patent eligibility concerns medical methods. The Patent Act explicitly excludes methods of treatment from patentability. This means that digital health inventions that involve disease diagnosis, treatment, or disease prevention may be ineligible for patent protection.
However, the act does not define a ‘method of treatment’, leaving room for interpretation. For example, some digital health inventions may involve software monitoring patient health and providing real-time feedback to healthcare providers without diagnosing or treating a specific disease.
Whether these inventions are considered ‘methods of treatment’ and, therefore ineligible for patent protection is a question that remains to be answered.
Artificial Intelligence
Artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly being used in the digital health space to develop predictive models, personalise treatment plans, and analyse large datasets. However, the question of whether AI can be patented is still up for debate. While the Patent Act does not explicitly exclude AI from patent eligibility, the Indian Patent Office has yet to grant a patent for an invention that relies solely on AI. This is partly because AI is often seen as a tool or technique rather than an invention in its own right. However, as AI continues to play a more prominent role in digital health innovation, patent offices and courts will likely be called upon to clarify its patent eligibility.
Data Privacy
Digital health inventions often involve collecting, storing, and analysing large amounts of sensitive health data. Ensuring the privacy and security of this data is crucial, both from a regulatory perspective and to maintain patient trust. However, navigating the legal and regulatory landscape around data privacy can be challenging.
In India, the Personal Data Protection Bill, which is currently under consideration, would establish a framework for collecting, using and storing personal data. However, the bill is still in its early stages, and it remains to be seen how it will impact digital health innovation and patent eligibility.
How to Navigate Uncertainty in Digital Health Patent Eligibility?
Despite the challenges posed by patent eligibility in the digital health space, there are steps that innovators can take to navigate these uncertainties and protect their inventions. The following are some key strategies for navigating uncertainty in digital health patent eligibility:
- Conduct a thorough patentability search: Before filing a patent application, it is important to conduct a thorough search to determine whether your invention is eligible for patent protection. This helps identify potential roadblocks and allows you to adjust your strategy accordingly.
- Work with experienced patent attorneys: Digital health inventions can be complex and multifaceted, making it essential to work with experienced patent attorneys who understand the legal and regulatory landscape. Attorneys can guide patent eligibility, as well as help to draft strong patent applications that are more likely to be accepted by patent offices.
- Be aware of emerging legal and regulatory frameworks: The legal and regulatory landscape around digital health is rapidly evolving, making it important to stay up-to-date on new laws and regulations that may impact patent eligibility. This can help innovators to anticipate potential challenges and adjust their strategies accordingly.
- Consider alternative forms of protection: While patents are an important form of protection for digital health inventions, they are not the only option. Innovators may also consider other forms of protection, such as trade secrets or copyright, which may offer additional layers of protection.
Conclusion
Navigating uncertainty in digital health patent eligibility is a complex and challenging task. However, by staying up-to-date on emerging legal and regulatory frameworks, working with experienced patent attorneys, and considering alternative forms of protection, innovators can protect their inventions and bring them to market.
As the digital health field continues to grow and evolve, it is essential to remain vigilant and adaptable and seek expert guidance. Ultimately, the ability to navigate uncertainty in digital health patent eligibility will be key to unlocking the full potential of this exciting and rapidly growing field.
Vakilsearch can assist innovators in navigating uncertainty in digital health patent eligibility. As an experienced legal services provider, Vakilsearch can help with patentability searches, offer expert legal and regulatory framework guidance, and work with innovators to draft strong patent applications. With Vakilsearch’s support, innovators can confidently protect their inventions and bring them to market.
FAQs
Can you patent a digital technology?
Yes, you can patent a digital technology if it meets the requirements for patentability.
Can I license my patent?
Yes, you can give permission to others to use your patented technology through a licensing agreement.
What is the requirement for patent eligibility?
To be eligible for a patent, an invention should be new, not obvious, and have practical use. It should also fit into one of the eligible categories, like processes, machines, or compositions of matter.
Read More:-
