Streamline your tax compliance with our expert-assisted GSTR 9 & 9C services @ ₹14,999/-

Tax efficiency, interest avoidance, and financial control with advance payment @ 4999/-

Important Things to Know About RCR & It’s Provisions

There are a lot of things that can happen after a divorce. One possibility is that the partner wins what's called an RCR? What happens then? Read this blog to know more.

A not unusual phenomenon during 498a/DV litigation is that the spouse leaves her matrimonial domestic and starts living in a few different vicinities, thus denying her partner his conjugal rights. Some legal professionals will tell you that you should follow RCR, additionally known as Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act.

These attorneys are best looking to entangle you in a fruitless conflict that allows you to improve them at the price of ruining your existence. Avoid such lawyers like the plague. 

A petition for RCR is a petition to order the spouse to return the lower back to you. This is finished supposedly to permit the partner who desires to save the wedding to keep it.

Why the lawmakers covered this provision in the regulation on marriage and divorce in India is a mystery –considering that they knew perfectly properly that you couldn’t pressure an unwilling partner to cohabit with the inclined spouse, even though they are within the equal mattress.

What if the Partner wins RCR?

If the partner wins the RCR and they no longer be a part of you, you may be entitled to file for divorce after 12 months. This is the simplest benefit as a way to accrue to you. A detrimental order towards her will no longer curtail or abrogate her proper document for divorce.

Restitution of Conjugal Rights

What is the Impact on the Wife?

Further, the sluggish speed of Indian courts guarantees that the marriage is lengthy and lifeless before the aggrieved party can see their attempt to a conclusive degree within the courtroom system.

This will occupy a few years of your life and lead to the wastage of lakhs of rupees, and in the long run, even if you will be the winner, even the Supreme Court can’t force it.

Nobody can pressure your spouse to come back to you, although there is a courtroom order from the highest court docket.

Your unscrupulous legal professional may also say that the RCR petition insulates you from 498a. This is utter hogwash. An RCR petition no longer guard you against 498a in any way in any respect.

Remember, you are asking your spouse to return, and they are refusing to return. She can without difficulty declare that this is due to dowry cruelty through you and your circle of relatives –and certainly, that is what is invariably carried out via such other halves.

Ask yourself, in case you force your spouse with the resource of your own family court docket to inform why she has left you, and if she is angry at you, then what different direction stays for her than to accuse you of harassing or torturing her?

Important things to know about RCR

RCR is a terrible, horrible mistake for the criminal facet of your conflict. It approaches in effect that you are affirming that you have forgiven all the cruelties of your spouse, and that you do now not mind that she has left you; denied you sex and love; filed a DV case towards you and your dad and mom; filed 498a towards you and your mother and father; and all different similar movements took through her.

You lose your proper to report divorce on the grounds of cruelty the instant you record RCR. You nearly lose your right to document for divorce on any grounds for months, if not years, after your RCR has been determined through the highest court docket.

Further, you have to fight your RCR till the best court docket, after which you must combat again from the bottom to the best court to enforce the decree. Even at the quit, it is not enforceable in any respect.

There is every other provision in the HMA that when one birthday celebration succeeds in getting a wonderful decree due to their RCR petition, the parties must resume cohabitation within twelve months, failing which both birthday celebrations can break up decree.

Provisions for RCR 

This provision renders the complete RCR concept meaningless because the birthday party who wishes a divorce can lead the opposite celebration up the lawn by allowing them to win the RCR decree as quickly as feasible, and then the identical usage towards them.

This can be accomplished through not contesting the RCR petition; and, after that, now not resuming cohabitation within the succeeding year.

This ultimate outcome is a divorce decree on the quit of that duration, and the deserting celebration gets what they want.

The above passage explains why the perception that an RCR can stupid your spouse’s divorce petition is foolish. She receives pathways to divorce in this example, now not simply one.

Another humorous aspect exhibits the lopsided interpretation of the regulation utilising the judiciary. Is that wife can also file an RCR and a 498a simultaneously.

The courts do not interpret her RCR in this example to intend that she has condoned the putative cruelty of the partner.

They allow the 498a to be admitted and permit the partner to go through the illogical prison atrocity of a girl looking to send him to prison and bring him to her bedroom at the same time. 

An RCR petition can’t reduce your preservation expenditure either, as your wife has more than one pathway to get renovation from you.

India is the best-united state in the international where the spouse has at least four legal provisions enabling her to invite for renovation, and it’s impossible to forestall all four attacks if she is hell-bent on harassing you.

Further, you must note that because of section 24 of HMA, she can claim money from you to combat the case in opposition to you. And even though you can record the RCR case for your city,

The file to date overwhelmingly supports the probability that the felony struggle will be fought in her town.

Can the Wife Stay With the Partner After Submitting 498A?

Yes, she will be able to live inside the marital home. Now she is needed to document software within the said courtroom for cancelling her husband’s bail.

Also, she will be able to criticize inside the nearest police station regarding the equal.

What Happens When the Husband Files for Divorce First?

If the husband files first, he can decide to cancel the divorce, so long as the wife hasn’t filed a reaction. The husband will have time till the wife files an answer to the grievance to cancel the divorce.

By submitting first, the husband can be the plaintiff, and the wife might be the defendant.

Click here to know more about mutual divorce process

Can the Partner File a Defamation Case Against the Spouse?

Since no locating is given at the allegations made by way of your wife as such, it’s miles premature to proceed with your spouse. Further, the documentary evidence might be read with oral proof of witnesses produced via the prosecution.

Is 498A Valid After a Divorce?

There can not be an FIR against a person and his family members for cruelty prices after divorce. If all of the divorce formalities are completed, then Section 498A will no longer be attracted. You can file a police criticism against your spouse.

What Happens if 498A Proves False?

Social Effects of a proven fake case of 498A For no-fault, the accused’s family is taken to prison right now after the wife accommodates a criticism. Since this offence is non-compoundable, the complaint can not be withdrawn, which results in a direct issue in any scope of reconciliation among the couple.

How Many Dowry Cases Are Faux?

While the file suggests about five.5 Lakh instances of 498a / Dowry are registered as a minimum 70% are acquittals, and the wife cannot prove the prices in opposition to them. It’s a misuse of the supply, and plenty of people use this as a weapon toward guys and their family to settle the rankings. You can also check the Alimony laws in India to know more.

How Can You Prove a 498a Case is Fake?

A counter lawsuit can be filed via the person beneath Section 500 (Defamation) of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, for defamation. A case underneath this section may be filed in case a lady tries to malign the image of her husband and his parents via falsely accusing them below this phase and dragging them to court docket or jail.

How Can You Guard Yourself Against a False 498A?

File an FIR against your wife for false 498A criticism: You can also report an FIR against your wife for blackmailing or submitting a false 498A case. Police in India normally no longer favour such FIR. However in case you make your case foolproof, the police can’t deny you to document an FIR in opposition to your wife.

What to Do if a False Domestic Violence and Dowry Case is registered Against You?

  1. Be Defensive.
  2. Collect as many portions of evidence as viable.
  3. Safeguard your Family.
  4. Complaint approximately blackmailing, false allegations.
  5. Drawback of this move.
  6. What I endorse in such instances.
  7. File RCR 

Can I Sue My Wife for False Allegations?

You very well may be capable of suing your former partner. When a person lies and the lie hurts other people, even if it hurts best their reputations, the injured man or woman can sue for slander and may look for monetary damages.

What to Do if Someone Documents a False Grievance Towards You?

Where the character lodged a false FIR towards an Individual, that man or woman may additionally america182 of IPC report a grievance with the police officer with whom such FIR has been lodged or to his Senior police officer, who’s empowered record a case in opposition to such police officer who has lodged the FIR earlier than the Magistrate court.

Can I Document Someone for False Accusations?

Filing a false police file is a criminal offense and can be charged as a misdemeanor or a criminal. Suppose you make a decision to name the police and file a document of a fake crime in opposition to someone else. In that case, it will be taken into consideration a false police document.


This is considered one of the crucial judgments in managing the elements of prenuptial settlement among Hindus. In this case, a suit for the RCR was filed with the aid of a Hindu partner. The spouse relied on a settlement accomplished at the time of marriage with the aid of their guardians.

Accordingly, the husband might continually stay with his spouse at his mother-in-law’s residence and could now not be entitled to take her away. It became held that, underneath Hindu regulation, marriage, besides being an agreement, is a sacrament.

According to Vakilsearch, a circle of relatives-centric legal creativeness comes on the fee of upholding the rights of people. Get in touch with us to know more. 

Also, Read:

Subscribe to our newsletter blogs

Back to top button


Remove Adblocker Extension