A landmark judgment is an important court decision that goes beyond just resolving a dispute. It sets a reference for future similar cases, either by offering a new view on the law or by reinforcing established legal tenets against new situations. Such decisions guide future court rulings on related matters
Overview on Delhi’s Landmark Judgements
The Delhi High Court, which was founded on October 31, 1966, is 57 years old now. The Delhi high court has 36 rooms and manages civil and criminal cases. Since starting, it has handled tough cases. The court uses technology to work faster and better.
A landmark judgment is like a standout decision made by a court. Instead of just settling an issue for the people involved, it sets a clear example or rule for similar cases in the future. This can happen by introducing a fresh perspective on law or by emphasising well-known legal principles when new challenges come up. As time goes on, when other courts face related issues, they often look back at these landmark decisions to help them make their own judgments.
10 Landmark Judgements Made By Delhi Court
Centre-State Dispute Over Power Distribution:
In August 2016, the Delhi High Court clarified the ongoing tension between the central and state governments over their respective powers in Delhi. The court affirmed the authority of the Lieutenant-Governor (L-G) in areas such as public order, land, police, and services. Despite special provisions under Article 239 AA of the Constitution, Delhi remains a Union territory. Several cases initiated by the AAP government without the L-G’s approval were deemed illegal. The Delhi government later contested this decision.
National Herald Misappropriation Case:
Allegations of fraud and misappropriation of funds surrounded Congress leaders Sonia Gandhi, Rahul Gandhi, and others in connection with the National Herald newspaper. BJP’s Subramanian Swamy’s complaint led to the issue being brought before the Delhi High Court. The Gandhis and others faced trial, and the case saw extensive legal arguments, resulting in the court’s decision in December to proceed with the trial.
Click here to know more about Vakilsearch Judgement Page
Delhi University Photocopy Case:
The Delhi High Court’s verdict in this case set an important precedent in copyright law. The court rejected international publishers’ requests to prevent a Delhi University shop from photocopying textbooks for educational purposes. The decision emphasised that copyright shouldn’t hinder the spread of knowledge.
Call Drop Verdict:
The Delhi High Court supported a decision by the telecom regulator in January 2016, requiring telecom providers to compensate users for call drops. However, this mandatory compensation was overturned by the Supreme Court in May 2016.
WhatsApp’s Privacy Policy:
The Delhi High Court ruled in September 2016 that while WhatsApp could implement its new privacy policy, user data had to be protected. WhatsApp was prohibited from using data from users who deleted their accounts for commercial gain. This change in policy was challenged in court due to concerns over user privacy.
National Policy for App-Based Taxi Services:
The Delhi High Court aimed to clarify and streamline the regulations for app-based taxi services like Uber and Ola. The court made decisions on transitioning fleets to CNG and adherence to the modified Radio Taxi Scheme.
Delhi Government’s Audit of Discoms:
In 2014, an audit by the Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) was contested by three power distribution companies, arguing that the CAG wasn’t authorised to scrutinise private firms. However, their challenge to the Delhi government’s decision was accepted later in October.
Release of Juvenile Convict in Gang Rape Case:
The release of a juvenile convict involved in the 2012 gang rape and murder case in Delhi created significant controversy. After spending three years in a correctional home, the individual was allowed to be released, a decision that faced opposition but was ultimately upheld.
Hoffman-La Roche and Cipla’s Drug Patent Dispute:
Drug companies Hoffman-La Roche and Cipla were embroiled in a patent dispute. The Delhi High Court decided that Cipla infringed on Hoffman’s patent on a specific lung cancer drug. Despite this, Cipla faced no injunction due to the nearing expiration of Roche’s patent.
Recognition of Third Gender Rights:
In a pivotal case, the court ruled in favour of a 19-year-old transgender non-resident Indian who was forced by his parents to come to India to “reform” him. This judgment affirmed that gender identity and sexual orientation are integral to individual rights and dignity.
Insights Can We Extract from Delhi’s Landmark Judgments
Delhi’s court decisions over time give us a map of India’s changes in rules, values, and society. For many years, the city has been a stage where traditional ideas meet modern thoughts. Courts play a role in finding a middle ground. For instance, when talking about the digital world, courts help make sure that people shopping or using services online are treated fairly. This is a big step from the days before computers and smartphones.
But it’s not just about technology. Legal cases in Delhi have tackled issues about the sharing of ideas, how public services are run, and making sure everyone, no matter their background, gets fair treatment. Think of the courts as the referees in a game where the rules aren’t always clear. They make tough calls to keep things fair.
There have been times when the rights of writers were questioned because students copied their books. There were also times when big companies were in court because of the way they provided phone or internet services. And, very importantly, courts have stood up for people who sometimes get left out, like those who don’t identify as strictly male or female.
All of these cases, and many more, paint a picture. It’s a picture of a country that’s growing, changing, and learning. And in all of this, the courts in Delhi act as guides, helping steer India in the right direction. They are a reflection of the nation’s journey and ambitions.
Conclusion
When it comes to knowing about laws or judgements, we have got the best judgement page at Vakilsearch. You can search for 5 million judgments at Vakilsearch. To talk to a lawyer at Vakilsearch and sign up to receive legal guidance and access over 5 million judgments, the steps to be followed are:
- Click on ‘Register’ on the Vakilsearch Judgement Page
- Then, you will be asked to enter the phone number and enter the respective OTP
- Then, choose between the two options and enter the necessary details.
- Pay the required fee to talk to our lawyers
- Clear all your queries!
Read More:
- Ultimate Judgment Search Portal Guide
- Top 5 Inspector General of Registration Judgments
- Indian Legal System: An Overview
