Streamline your tax compliance with our expert-assisted GSTR 9 & 9C services @ ₹14,999/-

Tax efficiency, interest avoidance, and financial control with advance payment @ 4999/-
Non Disclosure Agreement

NDA Faults in the Future

Future Enterprise, a well-known company, became a defaulter when it failed to repay a loan worth ₹2, 911.51 crore. It has failed to repay this loan amount to its lenders, and there has been no response even after the review period has passed.

Future Enterprise and Future Group companies have been in grave trouble due to their lenders’ non-paying of the loan amount. The Securities and Exchange Board of India, SEBI, has decided to charge a hefty penalty amount of five lakhs because it failed to disclose everything in relation to the arbitration proceedings in the Singapore Arbitration Centre (SIAC).

There was a notice that FEL received about the start of the proceeding around October 5, 2020, and Future Retail Limited, by that time, had already filed an objection in front of SIAC on October 6, 2020. There was a loophole there, as the reference to the stock exchange disclosure under the provisions of the LODR Regulations was missing.

Along with that, the SEBI notice and the PIT regulations added to all the information about the said process of arbitration and also saw the passing of an order on October 25th, 2020. Learn more about the NDA Faults.

In-Depth Case Study of Future Group’s Non-disclosure Agreement

In October 2019, the e-commerce company Amazon and Future Coupons Limited signed a share subscription contract and an agreement to buy shares with the promoters who belonged to Future Retail.

The parties clearly mentioned were Amazon and the promoter group from Future Enterprise. There was a clause mentioning the indemnity part. Any form of material information should not be disclosed, and if there was an intention to go by the terms laid down by SPA, then even that would have to be dealt with manually.

In the event of any problem, legal dispute, or any chance for arbitration, in case any of the two parties are residents of India, then the platform for arbitration will be India. If it is outside India, it will be decided by the party outside India. It was seen that Amazon is a company registered in the US, and hence, the place of legal arbitration was chosen to be Singapore.

The date of execution was October 2019, and the time duration also mentioned that the whole of the responsibility shouldered by Amazon should be considered completed before the closure of the 3rd year from the date of signing the contract, and it can be completed before the expiry of ten years from that day onward. The date mentioned is not before October 2022, and not more than the end of October 2020.

It was also mentioned that as a part of the investment process, Amazon got the rights to and share in the Biyani promoter group stake in Future Retail. To add, as part of the signed contract between the two companies, Amazon is given a call option to acquire some or all parts of the promoter’s shareholding in Future Enterprise, and this can be made effective between the third and tenth years.

There were certain restrictions on share transfer and the amount of share transfer to specific persons, which included the right of the first offer to Amazon only.There was a restriction given by Amazon about who could or could not invest in Future Retail, and some of these companies included Reliance, Walmart, Alibaba, and some of the best global players.There is another addition to the deal, which includes how Future Retail can sell Big Bazar brand and food supply unit Foodhall and Brand Factory’s retail and wholesale units to Reliance.

What Exactly Is an NDA?

If you are wondering what the NDA is all about, you must know that it means a non-disclosure agreement. It is a completely legal contract that is signed and put into action by two parties who agree on specific terms.

Two signatories are involved in various kinds of exchanges, and these can be intellectual, commercial, critical, conceptual, or technical property-related issues. Those two parties who are under legal binding and liability need to focus on the point that none of them discloses or gives the details about the contract or the property to any third party. This includes mobile and web applications as well.

An NDA is a typical contract that is almost like any sale contract or any kind of lease agreement conducted between two different parties, giving them the right cover against any type of threat or unforeseen result that might arise due to a breach in the contract. Future Group has had its fair share of problems in recent times, with companies like Amazon, banks like PNB, and many other business consortiums and individual lending companies. You can make the Non-disclosure Agreement Format as per your business demands and as per the users’ needs.

Step into stealth mode with our NDA Agreement Format, shielding your company’s confidential data from prying eyes..

SEBI Penalty Levied on the Future Group

The amount of loss incurred in the transaction process has not been disclosed by SEBI, but due to Future Group’s fault, many other companies and lenders have suffered. There were many points that Amazon raised over this huge issue:

  • Anything related to financial details was not explained to them. Amazon had acquired a stake of 49% in Future Enterprise Coupons, which was the promoter firm under Future Retail, and the deal amount was around 2000 crore.
  • There is another moot question about rights, authorities and share purchases—whether the Share Purchase Agreement shall also be able to include the voting rights as per the Companies Act 2013 as part of the investment plans and other legal obligations.
  • According to the SEBI guidelines, Amazon can be referred to as the acquirer, and as an individual or in collaboration with relevant groups, Amazon can acquire voting rights and shares, as well as gain significant control over the target company.
  • The acquisitional features are listed in section 2 (1) (b), under the share subscription coupons between Future Enterprise and Amazon.

Conclusion

In the country’s apex court, the Supreme Court has already said that it is a lengthy judgment, and it reserves its verdict on the plea of Future Group. The verdict on the NDA is a major issue. The bench comprised famous judges like A S Bopanna and Hima Kohli, who declared that the Delhi High Court could be given the right to hear the statutory appeals made by Future Enterprise against the sentence given in SIAC, FRL, and FCPL moved to the highest courts of order because of the complications remaining intact, as forwarded to SIAC by Amazon. Get to know about the NDA Faults by Visiting us at Vakilsearch.

FAQs On NDA Faults in Future for the Indian Audience

What are the common NDA faults businesses should watch out for in the future?

How can NDA agreements be improved to avoid potential pitfalls down the line?

Clearly define what constitutes confidential information. Specify the obligations of the receiving party. Include a defined time frame and renewal provisions.

What legal consequences might arise from NDA faults in the future?

Damages or financial penalties. Injunctions to prevent further disclosure. Potential reputational harm.

Are there any specific industries more susceptible to NDA faults than others?

Tech, pharmaceuticals, and finance are often at the forefront due to the sensitive nature of their information.

How can companies ensure their NDAs are future-proof and adaptable to changing circumstances?

Regularly review and update terms. Ensure adaptability clauses are included.

What are some real-life examples of NDA failures and the lessons we can learn from them?

In India, the Piramal Enterprises vs. Vodafone case highlighted the importance of clearly defining 'confidential information'.

How do technological advancements impact NDA enforcement and potential vulnerabilities in the future?

Digital tracking, AI, and blockchain may aid enforcement. However, digital leaks and cyber threats pose challenges.

Are there any best practices for drafting a comprehensive NDA that minimises future risks?

When creating NDAs, think about why and how you're sharing information. Include who's involved, what information is confidential, how long it's shared for, and what the receiver should do with it.

What role do employee training and awareness play in preventing NDA faults from occurring?

Regular workshops on the importance and implications of NDAs. Instil a culture of confidentiality.

How do international business transactions and global regulations influence NDA vulnerabilities in the future?

Consideration of data protection regulations in countries involved, like GDPR in Europe, can influence the clauses in NDAs. Understanding India's evolving position in global trade also matters.

Read More:


Subscribe to our newsletter blogs

Back to top button

Adblocker

Remove Adblocker Extension