Explore the impact of Geographical Indication (GI) tags on India's export market. Uncover how these tags contribute to boosting the country's global trade and preserving cultural heritage
Introduction
Geographical Indications (GI) tags serve a pivotal role in preserving the authenticity of products by linking them to their specific places of origin. In India, the GI tag system has become a valuable tool for protecting distinctive regional goods. This article explores the difference between a GI tag and a trademark, the functioning of GI tags, their impact on Indian exports, and the role of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) in regulating intellectual property rights.
Understanding the Distinction: GI Tags vs. Trademarks
Geographical indications serve as a certification that a product originates from a specific geographic location and possesses qualities or a reputation due to that origin. In contrast, trademarks distinguish products or services as originating from a specific business. This fundamental difference is vital for safeguarding the identity and uniqueness of both the product and the business.
The significance of this distinction lies in the dual nature of GI tags. Not only do they authenticate a product’s origin, but they also connect it to the distinctive qualities influenced by the geographical location of production. This creates a unique bond between the product and its origin, a connection that becomes the cornerstone of the product’s identity and consumer perception.
The Functionality of GI Tags in India
Producers and exporters of distinctive regional goods have long sought protection from imitations and unauthorized use. The GI tag, officially known as Geographical Indication Status, has played a pivotal role in preserving these unique products. GI tags are applied to natural, agricultural, or manufactured products, verifying their origin and production. While the system offers a mechanism for local control over production and sales, challenges persist, especially in the absence of a multilateral GI registration system under the WTO.
To understand the effectiveness of GI tags, it’s essential to delve into their functioning. GI tags act as a form of quality assurance, ensuring that products with a specific tag adhere to the defined standards and characteristics associated with their geographical origin. This not only protects consumers from false advertising and counterfeit goods but also prevents manufacturers from undervaluing their products.
GI Tags and Trademarks: A Comparative Analysis
A GI tag restricts the production of a specific commodity to a defined location, ensuring its authenticity. In contrast, trademarks allow a company to produce its branded product anywhere in the world. The protection offered by GI tags serves as a valuable outcome in institutionalizing the reputation of products, making them more expensive and enhancing the income of exporters.
The impact of this distinction becomes evident when considering the production scope. A product with a GI tag can only be produced in a specific geographical area, reinforcing the connection between the product and its origin. In contrast, a trademarked product can be manufactured by the same company in various locations globally. This distinction becomes critical in addressing issues such as asymmetric information and preventing free-riding on the reputation of authentic products.
Who Benefits From GI Tags?
The benefits of GI tags extend beyond national boundaries. While they provide product recognition and protection for developed countries, they act as insurance for poorer economies. In countries where production occurs in rural regions, GI tags assist producers who lack the financial means for extensive branding, helping them build brand equity.
In essence, GI tags become a tool for economic empowerment, especially for regions with limited marketing resources. The unique characteristics and reputation associated with GI-tagged products contribute to their marketability, allowing producers in economically challenged areas to gain recognition on a global scale. This, in turn, enhances the economic viability of local industries, fostering sustainable development.
The WTO and India: A Regulatory Framework
The Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS), overseen by the World Trade Organisation (WTO), introduced the concept of the GI tag. Despite criticism, TRIPS has set criteria for protecting intellectual property (IP) rights. The absence of a multilateral GI registration system under the WTO, except for wines and spirits, highlights the importance of national registration for GI tags.
The international landscape governing GI tags raises several questions. How do GI tags function on a global scale, and what role does the WTO play in shaping the regulations surrounding them? TRIPS defines the protection of GIs in Articles 22 and 23. According to Article 22, GIs are regulated to avoid giving the public false information and to stop unfair competition, and as a result, products covered by this article are given the usual protection. Contrarily, Article 23 focuses specifically on GI tags for wines and spirits, providing a higher level of protection.
The multiple-sided system underscores the complexity of GI tags and their regulation. While TRIPS sets the groundwork, individual countries must navigate the intricacies of national registration systems to ensure the effectiveness of GI tags. The absence of a comprehensive international framework emphasizes the need for proactive measures at the national level to safeguard the interests of producers and consumers.
Case Study: Darjeeling Tea and GI Tags
The first product in India to receive a GI tag was Darjeeling tea. The GI tag has proven to be a strategic move for the Darjeeling tea industry, ensuring the authenticity of the product. However, challenges persist in the enforcement of laws, requiring stricter government intervention. The Darjeeling tea case serves as an example of the impact of GI tags on product authenticity and the need for effective implementation.
The journey of Darjeeling tea highlights the dual role of GI tags in protecting products and educating consumers. While the GI tag authenticates the origin of Darjeeling tea, ensuring that it meets the established standards, its impact on sales and market perception requires time and continuous efforts. Partner Girish Sarda of Nathmulls Tea notes, “The GI tag was a smart move for the Darjeeling tea business because it ensures the items are real before they are delivered. The majority of the tea that was previously exported under the name Darjeeling tea was false.”
Sarda emphasizes that the impact on sales will take time due to the complexities of enforcing laws and ensuring adherence to standards. The GI tag is a valuable tool, but its effectiveness is closely tied to the commitment of authorities and industry stakeholders in upholding its integrity.
Challenges and Recommendations for India’s GI Tag System
Despite the benefits of GI tags, challenges such as unauthorized use and a lack of a streamlined international registration system persist. To enhance the effectiveness of GI tags for Indian exports, the government must address issues such as fund shortages, market sluggishness, and the application of rules and regulations. Government intervention and awareness campaigns are crucial for leveraging GI tags to break into the global market.
The challenges facing India’s GI tag system necessitate a proactive approach. One key challenge is the unauthorized use of GI tags, which compromises the authenticity and reputation of genuine products. Currently, it is technically prohibited for unauthorized users to utilize GI tags, but there is no effective way to prevent it. For instance, if a Kenyan vendor wishes to sell rice as Indian basmati rice without authorization, the Indian government can write to Kenyan authorities, but the resolution of such cases demands significant time and effort.
The need for a more robust international framework becomes apparent in cases where GI tags cross borders. The absence of a multilateral GI registration system, except for wines and spirits, underscores the urgency of establishing comprehensive regulations that facilitate international cooperation. While national registration is a crucial step, a harmonized global approach is essential to ensure the seamless protection of GI-tagged products on a broader scale
Conclusion
Geographical Indication (GI) tags are instrumental in preserving the authenticity of regional products and boosting the income of exporters. While India has made significant strides in implementing the GI tag system, challenges remain. Government intervention, awareness campaigns, and a robust regulatory framework are essential to maximize the benefits of GI tags for Indian exports.
As India navigates the global market, the effective utilization of GI tags will play a pivotal role in showcasing the nation’s diverse and unique products. The journey from the inception of the GI tag system to its current state illustrates the multifaceted nature of challenges and opportunities.
Proactive measures at both the national and international levels are imperative to ensure the continued success of GI tags in preserving the identity of products and contributing to the economic growth of regions around the world.
To know more about GI tags or to boost your exports, get in touch with Vakilsearch experts right away!
